5 Best Plush Dog Toys (Reviews Updated 2024)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

5 Best Plush Dog Toy Reviews

Those soft, cuddly, colorful, and fun-shaped plush dog toys are so appealing! You just can’t help but want to grab as many as you can so that your pooch can enjoy hours of playtime. But much to your dismay, instead of lasting for hours, most of the plush toys you offer your furry friend only last a few minutes.

If you’re tired of spending money on plush toys that are torn to shreds and reduced to a pile of stuffing, then you’re going to want to check out the stuffed toys for dogs that we’ve rounded up!

Below, you’ll find a collection of five of the most durable plush dog toys on the market. Check out our dog plush toy reviews to find out which your dog will like best.

Best Plush Dog Toys


1. Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog ToyDo you remember that oh-so cute puppet Lamb Chop from when you were a child? Even if you don’t, this super sweet plush dog toy will make you swoon; that’s how adorable it is! It’s designed to look just like Lamb Chop, that famous puppet, and it is sure to be a big hit with your furry friend – and every member of your family!

This super plush dog toy feels so soft and smooth that it’s hard not to want to cuddle it! In fact, don’t be surprised if you find your pooch curling up with it in his dog bed at naptime! But it’s not just for cuddling; it’s also for serious playing. It features a durable squeaker that your furry friend will love chasing and chomping on to hear the delightful sound that it makes. The plush material is soft enough to chew on and won’t cause any injuries when it’s caught in mid-air; however, it’s also extremely durable, so it should be able to withstand even the most aggressive games of tug-o-war. The stitching in this plush dog toy is so well done that it will be hard for your four-legged pal to tear through it. He’ll also be instantly drawn to the bright red colors of the front paws and tongue! Available in three sizes; a mini (6 inches), a regular (10 inches) and a jumbo (24 inches), you’ll be able to find an option that will work for your pup, whether he’s a tiny Yorkshire terrier, a medium-sized Beagle, or a massive Mastiff. Based on the reviews that we read, most of the customers who purchased this plush dog toy were very happy with it; in fact, many said that it is their dogs’ favorite toy!

What We Like About It

  • Features an adorable Lamb Chop design
  • Super plush for great cuddling
  • Very durable for chewing and intense playing
  • Lightweight for easy launching
  • A built-in squeaker will keep your pup coming back for more
  • Available in three sizes
  • It’s very affordable

Reasons to Complain

  • Some pet parents said that the squeak was too loud for their liking
  • Others said that it didn’t last long

Final Verdict: We were very impressed with the Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy. We found it to be very durable and super plush, and all of our canine friends that we used it with just loved it!

View on Amazon


2. KONG Cozie Marvin the Moose Plush Dog Toy

Kong Cozie Marvin The Moose Plush Dog ToyFrom the makers of KONG, one of the most reputable manufacturers of various types of dog toys – including chew toys for dogs, puppy teething toys, toys for hyper dogs, rope and tug toys, and water toys for dogs – comes this super durable, yet incredibly plush and oh-so fun Marvin the Moose Plush Dog Toy. It features an extra layer of material and superior stitching, which gives it added toughness, so it has a better chance of withstanding rough play sessions, serious chewing, and intense tugging.

The attractive moose design will definitely appeal to your pup, and he’ll find it hard to resist the built-in squeaker, which offers just enough squeak (many other squeak toys are obnoxiously loud). If your furry friend has an incredibly powerful jaw – like a West Highland White terrier, a Rottweiler, an American Bulldog, a Doberman, a German Shepherd, or Rhodesian Ridgeback – and he does manage to rip it open, you’ll love that it’s made with a minimal about of stuffing, so there will be less of a mess to clean up. It’s also available in two sizes – small and medium – so you can choose the perfect option for your four-legged baby. According to most pet parents, this plush dog toy is very well made, super cuddly, and extremely durable.

What We Like About It

  • Very durable for a plush toy
  • Super soft
  • Features a cute moose design
  • Built-in squeaker adds more appeal
  • Lightweight for easy throwing
  • Less stuffing = less mess
  • Affordable price tag

Reasons to Complain

  • Some customers did say that it didn’t last as long as they hoped it would

Final Verdict: If you’re looking for the most durable stuffed dog toy, you won’t find much better than the KONG Cozie Marvin the Moose Plush Dog Toy. The moose design and the built-in squeaker makes it fun, extra material and solid stitching makes it sturdy, and the softness makes it nice and cuddly.

View on Amazon View on Chewy


3. Zippy Paws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toys

Zippypaws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog ToysLet’s face it: if your pup has a super powerful jaw or he is an aggressive chewer, chances are that he’s going to break through even the most durable plush dog toy; however, that doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t offer them to him – or have to clean up a huge mess! The Zippy Paws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toys is exactly what it sounds like: a plush toy that contains absolutely no stuffing! Actually, it’s a set of THREE dog toys!

Since there’s no stuffing in these plush toys, they last longer; and if they do get damages, you’ll have less of a mess to clean up. The toys are made to resemble three fun woodland creatures: a raccoon, a squirrel, and a fox. Each toy features two built-in squeakers, which ups the fun equation. All of the toys are lightweight, so they are easy to toss and fling; plus, they’re soft, so mouths and hands won’t be harmed. This set of three plush dog toys is recommended for use with medium-sized breeds, such as a Basset Hound, a Rough Collie, an Australian Shepherd, a Chow Chow, or an English Springer Spaniel. According to the reviews that were published, most of the pet parents who used these toys said that their fur-babies just loved them! The no-stuffing design made them super appealing, and so did the squeakers.

What We Like About It

  • Comes with three different plush toys
  • The design of each toy is super cute
  • Made of soft fleece material
  • Well-stitched
  • No stuffing, so they’ll last longer and there’s less of a mess to clean up
  • Built-in squeakers
  • Lightweight design
  • Affordably priced

Reasons to Complain

  • A few customers noted that while the plush toy stayed in-tact, the squeakers broke rather quickly

Final Verdict: The Zippy Paws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toys comes with a pack of three different stuffing-free plush toys, so they really are a great value for the money. The no stuffing design makes them last longer and reduces messes, and the built-in squeaker adds to the fun.

View on Amazon View on Chewy


4. Frisco Plush Squeaking Bear Dog Toy

Frisco Plush Squeaking Bear Dog ToyNext up on our list of the best plush dog toys is the Frisco Plush Squeaking Bear Dog Toy. Made of durable, yet soft polyester, this is the perfect stuffed teddy bear for your dog to curl up with for a nap, or to play with when he’s feeling frisky. It’s stuffed with minimal amounts of material, which helps to reduces the desire to chew right through it; but, if your pooch does tear it open, you’ll have less of a mess to contend with.

This plush, cuddly, teddy bear is lightweight, so you’ll have no problems tossing it around, and your pup won’t have any issues catching it, because it won’t harm his mouth. It’s also available in several sizes, so you can find the perfect fit for your canine companion. Based on the reviews that we read, most of the customers who have used this plush dog toy said that they – and their four-legged friends – were very happy with it. They said that it’s soft and much more durable than other plush dog toys they have used in the past.

What We Like About It

  • Features a classic teddy bear design
  • Made of soft, cuddly, yet durable polyester
  • Less stuffing = less mess
  • Most users said that it lasts longer than other plush dog toys they’ve used
  • Affordably priced

Reasons to Complain

  • Some customers said that it didn’t last as long as they hoped that it would

Final Verdict: The Frisco Plush Squeaking Bear Dog Toy is soft, cuddly, durable, and adorably cute. It’s great for playing and for cuddling. Since they’re less stuffing, it will last longer and there’s less of a mess to clean up.

View on Chewy


5. Outward Hound HedgehogZ Plush Dog Toy

Outward Hound Hedgehogz Plush Dog ToyLast – but most certainly not least – on our list of the best plush toys for dogs – is the Outward Hound HedgehogZ Plush Dog Toy. As the name suggests, it features a super cute hedgehog design that your pup will love! It’s also full of squeakers, which your dog will love chomping on and chasing after. The faux fur is super soft, yet sturdy, and the shape is perfect for a canine’s mouth; your pooch will have no trouble handling this toy.

According to the reviews that we read, most of the people who have used this plush dog toys stated that they were very impressed with it. They noted that their pups’ loved the shape and the sound, and pet parents said that it lasted longer than other plush dog toys. We agree with all of those statements! Our furry friends just loved this toy, and they had a hard time trying to tear them open.

What We Like About It

  • Features minimal seams to prevent tearing
  • Made with soft faux fur, which is extra cuddle
  • The design is adorable
  • The shape is perfect for a canine’s mouth
  • Features built-in noisemakers for added fun
  • More durable than other plush toys we’ve used

Final Verdict: Overall, we were very pleased with the Outward Hound HeadgehogZ Plush Dog Toy. It’s cute, fun, soft, cuddly, and it’s more durable than other plush toys we’ve tried; what more could you want?

View on Amazon View on Chewy


Plush Dog Toys Buyer’s Guide

As the leader of your canine companion’s pack, he looks to you to provide for all of his needs. You keep his dog bowl full of the highest quality, most delicious, and most nutritious dog food from one of the most reputable dog food brands; you offer him a dog treat to reinforce good behavior (or just to show him that you love him); you might even take him on regular road trips (with a dog seat belt a dog car seat cover, of course!), and you definitely make sure that you offer him plenty of love and cuddles, too. You don’t mind doing all that you do for your four-legged baby, either; after all, he’s more than just a pet: he’s a member of your family!

Of all the things you can do for your pooch, playing with him on a regular basis is one of the most important. There are so many different types of toys to choose from, too, such as interactive dog toys, puzzle toys for dogs, automatic fetch machines, and puppy toys, too. But the most classic of all dog toys is, without a doubt, the plush dog toy.

Why should you use plush dog toys to play with your pooch? What factors should you consider when selecting a plush toy for dogs? Find the answers to these questions below so that you can make the best, most entertaining, and safest choice for your furry friend.

The Benefits of Plush Dog Toys

It’s no secret that dogs love to play! Not only does playtime keep your pup entertained, but it’s also a great way to provide him with the exercise that he needs to maintain a healthy weight (along with feeding him a well-balanced and nutritious dog food and taking him for regular walks on a well-fitted dog harness or dog collar). Playing also prevents him from becoming board and engaging in destructive behavior and it can even keep anxiety at-bay (if you’re pooch suffers from serious anxiety, you might want to consider giving CBD oil for dogs a try). Regular playing also encourages you and your pooch to bond, and will allow him to develop more trust in you; and trust is so crucial in a healthy pet-and-owner relationship.

Given all of these benefits, there’s no doubt that you should be offering your pet plenty of opportunities to play. But why should you use plush dog toys as opposed to any other option? Well, every type of dog toy definitely offers its benefits, but plush toys for dogs are appealing because:

  • They’re softer, which means that they are safe to chew on and are less likely to cause injuries
  • They’re cuddly, and sometimes dogs like to cuddle up with something soft, as it can offer them great comfort – much like a child likes to hold onto a stuffed animal or you might like to hug a pillow while you sleep
  • They’re appealing; canines just love chasing after plush toys and trying to tear them to shreds. It’s their animal instinct!
  • They’re affordable. Generally speaking, plush toys are a lot less expensive than other types of dog toys

It’s easy to see why your furry pal will love playing with plush toys, and why you should make sure that you have plenty of them available for him!

Factors to Consider

In order to ensure that you are selecting the best plush toy for your dog, consider the following factors:

  • Durability; the more durable it is, the longer it will last
  • The design; it should be appealing to your pup and easy for him to handle
  • Appeal; the best dog toys contain squeakers or crunchy material that makes noise and attracts their attention
  • The size; you want to make sure the toy is an appropriate size for you pooch; if it’s too large, he won’t be able to handle it, but if it’s too small, he could choke on it

Summing It Up

If you’re a pet parent, you are definitely going to want to have a nice collection of dog toys available at all times. The options on this list are super plush, and much more durable and longer lasting than a lot of the other plush toys we’ve tried. And at the price, you could afford to buy all five without breaking the bank!

Recommended Reading:


Humane Society

Well Trained Mind